Wednesday, December 14, 2011

Review: Urban Decay Naked 2

This video was just on my first impressions in the first week I received it.

Hi Friends!  I just want to first say that I am just being honest and my intention is not to be rude or harsh.  I want you all to know that I will always be honest about my feeling on a product no matter what.  If you love this palette, my opinion shouldn’t sway your thoughts either way.  Sometimes I feed into the hype about something and it will make me buy or even love a product for month.  I have to stop and really evaluate whether I like something or if I just think I do because others rave about it.  That being said, I was completely enamored with the Naked 2 Palette.  So many of us were so excited to try and get it with the first batch of 5000.  When the site finally allowed me to purchase, I felt as if I was in the cool club for a minute.  I ordered 3 and then went back and ordered 3 more (moment of insanity).  I sort of snapped back into reality and canceled the second order of 3.  Anyway, I was clearly just as excited as everyone else.  My excitement has diminished a bit because of the quality and pigmentation of this product.  I found it easier to make bulletins of the pros and cons.

Packaging A-
I love the hard case, but find it a bit inconvenient to have to pry it open every time I use it in one application.  I close it when I set it down so they don’t get damaged so I open and close the case about 3 times during one sitting.  Also, closing is odd.  Sometimes it does not want to snap in one of the corners and when it does… out!  It snaps down really hard.

Brush A-
I love the blending side of this brush so much!  It is defiantly of my new favorite brushes.  It is the perfect size for getting your outer V and it blends eyeshadow so nicely and gives a clean professional look.  I have not had any shedding or bleeding so I am very happy about that.  The flat shader or lay down side is odd to me.  It is synthetic which makes it difficult to pick up a good amount of product.  I do like this brush for liquid or cream products, but for the actual shadow, not so much.  It would also be good for a foiled eyeshadow look since the product would be damp. 

Foxy A
I enjoy this color very much.  It is a bit chalky, but no more than most matte shades that I work with.  This is a matte shade and the pigmentation is good, but it can be sheered out to a very light wash of color.  I use this color every time I use the palette and I find it very nice for blending out any crease color I use.  The fallout is minimal.  The color selection is great for someone my skin toned (MAC NC35) or lighter.  I don’t feel like women of color would find this shade to be a very helpful nude or highlight color unless blended out to be sheer to almost nonexistent.

Half Baked A

I know a lot of you were disappointed with the selection of Half Baked being added to the Naked 2.  It is in a lot of the existing Urban Decay Palettes and some might say it’s overdone.  I personally think this color is beautiful for all skin tomes and is a great color to use in the fall and winter for a nice warm touch of gold and in the spring/summer for a sheer wash of warmth with just a touch of mascara.  It is very easy to use and looks great alone or as a lid color with a neutral smoky eye.  This is defiantly a shimmery color with great pigmentation.  The fall out is moderate so I would suggest foundation as a last step when using this color.  This is also a great color to foil for a really intense pop of color with a lot of shine.     

Booty Call A-
This color has nice pigmentation with minimal fallout and is great for a highlight color on the cheekbones or down the center of your nose.  I am not a big fan of frosty light colors on the brow bone, but that is just a personal preference.  I will be using this palette when I travel so to have this color is really convenient for me because I don’t have to bring an extra product for my highlight.  However, I don’t feel as though I will use this color as an eyeshadow because it is a bit too frosty and pale for my taste.  The shimmer in it is so fine that it makes blending a dream which is key to having a clean highlighted cheekbone without looking like a disco ball.

Chopper B-
I like the concept of this color, meaning I like it in the pan and what I thought it could be.  On the eye it looks like an orangey-pink.  It does not suite my skin tone very well.  Its shimmery with chunky glitter in it that falls out when applied to the lid.  Urban Decay is not known for having awesome glitter shadows.  I have never been happy with these chunky colors that they seem so fond of.  The pigmentation is good and fallout other than glitter) is moderate.  It is defiantly going to be one of the least used colors in my palette.    

Tease A+
This shade is a cool toned taupe color with almost a mauve undertone.  I do find the quality of this shadow to be the best out of the 3 matte shades.  It is smooth and blends very nicely.  The fallout is minimal.  It does not suite my skin tone as well as buck (a warm med matte brown) from the original Naked palette.  I find I have to warm it up with a color outside of this palette, although this does not sway my feelings about how much I do like this shadow.  It is great quality and can be sheared out nicely.  It is great for you mid tone between your crease and brow bone.  This would be great for weddings or photo shoots in general.  I’m a big fan of this color.   

Snakebite A
This is a shimmery color with moderate fallout.  It is easily blended and can be used to give a gradient effect quite easily.  You could use this sheered out in your crease and then build up pigmentation in your outer V for a one step smoky eye.  It is a unique color and would look very beautiful on most skin tones.  I find myself using this color often when I reach for this palette. 

Suspect D-
This is a shimmery champagne color.  I have heard people rave about the pigmentation in it which leave me wondering if I ended up getting a “bad batch”.  This color for me had almost 0 payoff unless I built it up about 3 times.  It did not pick up on my lay down brush very well and would ball up into tiny fluffy balls that end up all over my face.  I have tried using this with different brushes, but nothing works.  You might try this as a wet shadow suing water or a mixing medium.  For me it was a fail because I have no use for it.

Pistol A-
This color is a shimmery silver brown.  It’s light and almost frosty looking.  This color has light to moderate fallout and would look beautiful on the lid with a winged Plum liner and some mascara.  Easy to wear, but I couldn’t see this being a blend out or crease color.  It only has the one use for me and that is the reason for the A- rating.        

Verve A
This is a very soft greyish pink color.  Strange, I know.  It is similar to Pistol in that I would only use this on my lid and possibly the inner tear duct.  The shimmer is so finely milled and it is like butter to apply.  It blends out really easily so be careful to not blend it away completely.  Not a color I would use every day, but a great option to have.  I don’t find that it was completely necessary to have in this palette.  I would have loved to have seen Naked, from the original, in its place.

This is a rose gold or dusty pink color.  It is shimmery and I find it chunky although there is no actual glitter.  The shimmer is not as fine as some of the others.  It is a great lid color.  This is a great color for applying with your fingers to the lid and just adding some mascara.  I find these shimmery colors to have the same uses for me so I’m just “eh” about it.  Nice color pay off and moderate to a lot of fallout. 

Busted B-
This is an aborigine color with tiny flex of glitter.  The pigmentation is great and the color is unique and I am a big fan of this deep eggplant shade.  The fallout is quite bad and it does not blend as nicely as I would have liked it to.  I wanted this to be the perfect outer V color, but I find it hard to work with and disappointing.  It is nice for the lower lash line or to use as a liner. 

Blackout D
This is a matte black shadow.  The fallout is minimal to moderate and the shadow is quite chalky, but pigmented.  Again, I wanted to love this because it was a staple color I was looking for in a palette.  This was probably the color I had the highest hopes for.  After all, how could you go wrong with a matte black???  This is hard to work with and if you blend it out too much it blends away.  I find that is it patchy and looks sloppy and quite muddy on the eyes.  I will probably stick to using this for a liner or to deepen my crease, but I am far from pleased with the quality and functionality of this shadow. 

All Around Rating C

All in all, I don’t find myself reaching for this palette like I thought I would.  I liked the concept of it because I thought it could be an all in one for me with a matte black and highlight and the shade range is much better than the original.  Unfortunately, I found myself reluctant to reach for this at all.  I had to force myself to use it because I promised I would use it for an entire week straight.  I will defiantly use this for travel, but not much more outside of this purpose.  I hope you enjoyed this and thank you so much for taking the time to stop by.  For amazing pictures of swatches and another opinion checkout

1 comment:

  1. I ended up returning the Tarte box after reading some more reviews after you returned yours. I didn't even open it, just brought it back to Sephora and got some other stuff. Since my mom was going to give that to me for Christmas she is going to give me the Naked 2 instead. A lot of the colors in there like Chopper (which I think will work well with my color eyes, or at least hope), Foxy, Tease, etc. are ones I've been eyeing already so I was excited that they'll be in there. I was hoping the quality would hold up in palette form. Since I love the Naked palette so much I automatically thought I would love this one and still hope I do. Thanks for being so honest though, I feel like I have a more level head going into it now. Wow I sound so serious, it's just makeup Heidi... Great post <3